✓Quick Takeaways
- A dick rating is a paid, personalized review of a fan's intimate photos — way more than just a number out of 10
- Charge $50+ for text and $100+ for video — most creators price too low and it kills their perceived value
- Always ask the fan's preference first: honest, flattering, or SPH — getting this wrong ruins the experience
- Never show a subscriber's photos in your rating video — it violates OnlyFans terms and can get you flagged
- Use ratings as a discovery tool: learn what the fan is into, then upsell to customs worth 5-10x more
- Set a 24-48 hour turnaround window and try to deliver early when you can
- For smaller sizes, rate 5-6 minimum and always find something genuinely positive to highlight
Most creators treat dick ratings like an afterthought. Quick $10 side hustle — send a number, move on. Meanwhile, the creators I manage at B9 charge $100+ for a single video rating. We've delivered over 243 ratings so far, and the ones who do this right turn every rating into a custom order pipeline worth 5-10x more. The difference? They don't just rate. They figure out what the fan is actually into — and then sell him exactly that. I'm Martin, chatting specialist at B9 Agency. Here's how we run dick ratings — real pricing, scripts that work, and the funnel strategy that turns a one-time order into recurring revenue.
What Is a Dick Rating (And Why It's Not Just a Number)
A dick rating is a paid service where a fan sends you an intimate photo, and you respond with a personalized score, reaction, and detailed feedback. Written message, voice note, or video — your choice. Sounds simple. And it is. But here's where most creators mess up. They think a dick rate means sending back "7/10, nice" and calling it a day. I've seen it hundreds of times across the creators we manage at B9. That two-word response is why their rating revenue dies after week one. A real dick rating covers specific details — length, girth, grooming, shape, overall vibe. It's personal. It's detailed. And when you do it right, it's the easiest money you'll make on OnlyFans.
It's a discovery tool
The real value of a dick rating isn't the $50-100 you charge. It's learning what this fan is actually into. Honest feedback? Worship? SPH? Once you know his preferences, you can sell him customs worth 5-10x more.
It builds trust fast
When a fan sends you something that personal and gets a thoughtful response back, he's hooked. That's a subscriber who tips, buys customs, and stays subscribed for months.
It's low effort, high margin
A solid text rating takes 5-10 minutes. A video rating takes 2-3 minutes to film. Compare that to a 20-minute custom video — the hourly rate on ratings is way better.
If you're searching "what are dick rates" or "what does dick rate mean" — it's all the same thing. Dick rating, dick rate, cock rating. The fan sends a photo, you give detailed feedback and a score. That's it.
Types of Dick Ratings — Honest, Worship, and SPH
Before you react to any photo, you need to know what the fan actually wants. This is the mistake I see constantly — creators jump straight into their response without asking first. There are three main types. Each one requires a completely different tone.
Honest rating
The most common request. The fan wants your genuine reaction — what you actually think about size, shape, grooming, and overall look. Be real, but be kind. Highlight what's working before you mention anything that isn't. For smaller guys, aim for a 5-6 minimum and always find something genuinely positive. A 3/10 should be reserved for extreme cases only.
Flattering rating (dick worship)
Pure praise. The fan wants to hear that his dick is the best thing you've ever seen. Go all in on compliments — size, shape, what you'd want to do with it. No holding back. If this doesn't come naturally, practice with a script before your first order.
SPH (small penis humiliation)
This is a specific fetish where the fan gets off on being mocked and degraded. It's more common than you'd think. But here's the critical thing — honest does NOT mean SPH. A fan asking for an honest rating isn't asking you to humiliate him. Always confirm what he wants before you start.
Always ask upfront: "Do you want my honest opinion, or is there anything specific you're into?" This one question prevents the biggest mistakes in dick ratings. Some fans want SPH but won't say it directly. Some want honest feedback but will be crushed by anything too blunt. Ask first, deliver second.
How Much to Charge (Stop Underpricing Your Ratings)
This is where most creators leave money on the table. I see it all the time — $5 for a written rating, $10 for a video. That's giving away your time for nothing. At B9, we've delivered over 243 ratings across our managed creators. Here's what we actually charge — and why it works.
Pricing trick: when a fan asks for a rating, offer three options — text ($50), audio ($75), video ($100+). Most fans pick the middle. This anchoring effect is the same reason restaurants put an expensive wine at the top of the menu. Check our OnlyFans pricing guide for more strategies like this.
| Format | B9 Pricing | Industry Average | Why the Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Text rating | $50+ | $5–15 | Detailed text takes 5-10 min of real effort |
| Audio rating | $75+ | $10–25 | Your voice adds intimacy fans will pay for |
| Video rating | $100+ | $25–50 | Most personal format with highest perceived value |
B9 Agency pricing vs. typical OnlyFans creator rates, 2026
dick ratings delivered by B9 creators
B9 Agency data
minimum for a video rating at B9
B9 Agency pricing
more than most creators charge
Industry comparison
Written vs. Video — Formats and the Pre-Recorded Debate
Every creator asks me this: should I offer text-only, or do I need to film video ratings too? Short answer — offer both. Let the fan decide. But you should know the tradeoffs before you set up your menu.
Never offer free dick ratings as a promo tactic. Once you set the price at zero, fans expect it every time. If someone sends an unsolicited photo without paying, don't open it. Respond with your menu and pricing instead. Train your fans to pay — don't train them to expect freebies.
“We don't do pre-recorded ratings at B9. Every response is custom to the fan. When someone pays $100 for a video rating and realizes it's generic, you've lost him forever. Fans compare notes. They notice when the reaction doesn't match their specific photo.”
— Martin, B9 Agency
✓Pros
- Text ratings are fast (5-10 minutes), can be done anywhere, and scale easily
- Video ratings command 2x the price and build way stronger fan connections
- Audio is a solid middle ground — personal but no camera or makeup needed
✕Cons
- Text-only feels impersonal to fans who want a real reaction
- Video requires looking presentable and having a clean filming setup every time
- Pre-recorded video ratings get exposed fast — fans talk to each other and compare
The Rating Framework — What to Actually Cover
Here's the framework we train chatters on at B9. Whether it's text or video, hit these points in this order. It takes a generic "nice dick" and turns it into something fans will pay $100+ for.
You can buy ready-made dick rating scripts on Etsy and tweak them for your style. Plenty of creators do this as a starting point. But over time, you'll develop your own approach that fans recognize and come back for. That personal touch is what builds repeat customers.
Open with their name and energy
Start personal. "Hey [name], just got your photos and I have to say..." Don't jump straight into measurements. Set the mood first. Your opening line determines whether this feels like a real reaction or a copy-paste template.
React to your first impression
What caught your eye first? The shape, the grooming, the size, the angle of the photo? Say it. This proves you actually looked instead of firing off something generic.
Rate the specifics — size, girth, shape, grooming
Go through each factor one by one: length, thickness, how it curves (if it does), head shape, and grooming. Be specific. "Your girth is solid and the grooming is clean" beats "nice dick" by a mile.
Call out what makes it unique
Every dick has something distinct — veins, shape, how it photographs, skin tone. Point it out. This is what separates a $50 rating from a $5 one. Fans remember when you noticed something nobody else did.
Score it and plant the upsell
Give your score out of 10 with a short reason why. Then leave the door open: "If you want to see how I'd react on video, that's even more fun..." This is your moment to turn a rating into a bigger sale.
From First DM to Delivery — The Full Process
Here's how the whole thing works from start to finish. This is the exact flow we use at B9 — from the moment a subscriber asks for a rating to the follow-up message after delivery. First thing: when a subscriber messages you, figure out what he actually wants. Is he after a dick rating? A custom video? Just chatting? The guys who want a rating usually come right out and say it. If they don't ask directly, you can offer it once you've built some rapport.
Critical rule: you cannot show a subscriber's photos in your video rating. That means no holding up his photo on screen, no having it visible while filming. You can describe what you see, react to it, reference specifics — but his actual photo stays private. Breaking this rule violates OnlyFans terms of service and can get your account flagged.
Confirm the request and ask preferences
Fan says he wants a rating. Ask: "Do you want my honest opinion, or is there anything specific you're into?" That one question tells you honest vs. flattering vs. SPH — and shows you know what you're doing.
Present your pricing
Lay out the options: text, audio, video. Give clear prices. If he pushes back, negotiate — but don't go below your floor. At B9, we always try to sell at the maximum price the fan will pay. Something is better than nothing, but don't race to the bottom.
Payment first, always
Never start work before the tip clears or the PPV unlocks. No exceptions. Send a tip link or lock it behind a PPV message at the agreed price.
Request clear photos
Ask for 2-3 well-lit shots from different angles. If his photos are blurry or taken in a messy room, say it: "Send me your best shots — good lighting, clean background. I want to give you a real assessment and photo quality matters."
Deliver within your stated window
24-48 hours is the standard turnaround. If you film on specific days (Tuesday and Thursday is common), say so upfront. Underpromise and overdeliver — if you say 48 hours and send it in 12, you look incredible.
Follow up with the upsell
Don't deliver and disappear. Send a follow-up: "Glad you liked that — if you ever want a more detailed video reaction, or something custom beyond just the rating, I'm down." This is how one $50 rating turns into a $200+ custom.
Dick Ratings as a Sales Funnel (What Nobody Tells You)
Here's my actual take on dick ratings, and it might surprise you: the rating itself isn't the product. It's the opener. Think about it. When a fan pays for a rating, he's telling you exactly what he's into. Honest feedback? He values authenticity — sell him girlfriend-experience customs. SPH? He's into domination — sell him findom content and humiliation sessions. Worship? He wants to feel desired — sell him personalized videos where you can't stop thinking about him. The rating is step one. Here's how we use it at B9.
Map the fan's preferences during the rating
Pay attention to how he responds. Does he tip extra when you mention something specific? Does he message back wanting more detail on one part? That's his trigger. Write it down. You'll use it later.
Always push for the maximum
At B9, we never settle for the first offer. Fan wants a text rating? Offer video. Wants video? Suggest adding his name or going topless for a premium. If he won't budge on price, we still sell at the highest amount he'll pay. But we always push up first.
Follow up within 24 hours of delivery
Don't wait for him to come back. Message: "Hey, I had fun with your rating yesterday. I've been thinking about doing a custom video where..." Plant the seed. Fans who already bought a rating are your warmest leads for bigger orders. This is exactly the kind of chatting strategy that separates amateur creators from pros.
“The dick rating is about finding out what the fan is actually into — what he likes — and then turning that into a custom. That's where the real money is.”
— Martin, B9 Agency
Handling the Awkward Stuff
Let's talk about the situations that make new creators freeze up. They will happen — guaranteed. And how you handle them decides whether you keep the fan or lose him for good.
Small sizes — be honest but kind
Rate 5-6 minimum. Always find something genuinely positive — grooming, shape, skin tone, how it photographs. One approach that works great: "It's perfect for oral because you can really get a mouthful." Focus on what IS there, not what isn't. Never laugh or look shocked, especially on video.
SPH boundaries and consent
Some fans want SPH but won't ask directly. Some say "honest" when they actually want humiliation. That's why you always clarify upfront. And even with SPH, there's a line. Stick to what they've agreed to. If you're not comfortable with humiliation content, say so — it's completely fine to skip this service.
Unsolicited photos without payment
Happens constantly. Fans fire off dick pics in DMs hoping for a free reaction. Don't open them. Don't engage. Respond with: "I'd love to rate you! Here's my menu and pricing. Pick your option and I'll give you my full honest opinion." Turn freeloaders into customers.
Scope creep — customs disguised as ratings
"Can you do a 10-minute topless video rating where you use my name and touch yourself?" That's not a rating. That's a full custom video. Know the difference and price it right: "That sounds like a custom, which starts at $X. A standard rating covers your score, my reaction, and detailed feedback on [list what's included]."
Terrible photo quality
9 out of 10 photos you'll get have awful lighting, messy backgrounds, or bizarre angles. It's normal — creators at B9 joke about this all the time. Work with what you get, but don't hesitate to ask for better shots: "Send me a clearer one with good lighting — I want to give you a real detailed rating."
If a fan gets upset about a rating score, stay calm. You can say: "This is my honest opinion based on what I saw — if you want a different style of rating next time (like a worship rating where I go all-in on the positives), I'm happy to do that too." Redirect the energy toward another paid service instead of arguing about the number.
Mistakes to Avoid
✕ Treating it as just a number
Sending "7/10, nice" is the fastest way to kill repeat business. Fans pay for detail, personality, and a genuine reaction — not two words and a score. If you're not willing to put in 5-10 minutes of effort, don't offer the service.
✕ Pricing at $5-10 per rating
Cheap pricing signals low value. When you charge $5, fans treat it like a $5 experience — and they won't come back. Price at $50+ for text and $100+ for video. You're offering an intimate, personal service. Act like it.
✕ Not asking about preferences first
Delivering an honest rating to a fan who wanted SPH — or humiliating someone who wanted genuine feedback — destroys the experience immediately. One question fixes this: "What are you looking for — honest opinion or something specific?"
✕ Showing the fan's photos in your video
This breaks OnlyFans terms of service. You can describe and react to what you see, but you cannot display their photos on screen during your recording. Getting flagged for this puts your entire account at risk.
✕ Delivering and disappearing
The rating is the start of the sale, not the end. If you send the rating and ghost, you're leaving the biggest revenue opportunity on the table. Every delivered rating should include a follow-up message that opens the door to customs, video calls, or sexting sessions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Summary
Dick ratings are the highest-margin service you can offer on OnlyFans. Minimal time investment, solid return — and when you treat them as a discovery tool instead of a throwaway product, the revenue multiplies. Start with three pricing tiers: text at $50+, audio at $75+, video at $100+. Personalize every single response. Always ask what the fan wants before you start. And never forget the follow-up after delivery. The biggest shift I see when creators get this right? They stop thinking of ratings as a side hustle and start treating them as their best sales funnel. One $100 rating that leads to a $300 custom is worth more than twenty $5 throwaways. If you're serious about making real money on OnlyFans, dick ratings belong on your menu today. And if you want an experienced chatting team running this for you — that's what we do at B9.
